The difference is striking, and it’s a question of tribe — not which one one should belong to, but whether one should belong at all.
Goldberg, like many who feel estranged from both major parties, has repeatedly argued for a set of principles. That confuses a great many people. We live in a hyper-partisan moment, a moment in which we are constantly being pushed or prodded into one tribe or the other, and it’s not so easy to keep the partisans, irrespective of affiliation, at bay. How often are we told that this is the “most important election of our lifetime,” or “everything” is at stake, or America is facing an “existential” crisis. The subtext, mindless and historically illiterate, is always the same: You’d better join my tribe now, or we’re all going to die. One feels for the sad souls who have jettisoned God for party; their struggle is not with the red or blue team, but with the great abyss, death, poetry, the human condition.
Longwell, whom I don’t know, strikes me as one of those people. A partisan. She belonged to a tribe, and then it spurned her, and, at first, she seemed committed to defending the principles that her old tribe once celebrated, but gradually she relinquished those principles in the service of a new tribe. Belonging to a team was the most important thing. Maybe the only thing. This is how one starts out working for an organization once helmed by William F. Buckley and winds up supporting Abdul El-Sayed. It’s only inconsistent if one doesn’t have much of an intellectual program, a set of principles, to betray in the first place.
I suspect that the reason so many of the most implacable Never Trumpers resent the likes of Goldberg is that people like Goldberg, wittingly or not, reveal the emptiness of the partisan. The lack of principle. The soullessness. This would strike the partisan as risible — presumably, Longwell would say she’s now a Democrat because she cares deeply about certain principles. But the partisan is confused or dishonest or both. The partisan has made so many compromises with herself she no longer knows what she believed way back when. Or whether she believed anything at all. All she knows is this is her team, and if you’re not on her team, you deserve nothing but scorn, mockery, contempt. You convince yourself that the only way to beat awful is with awful.