If critics of Zionism and Jewish self-determination didn’t want Jews to re-create a polity in the homeland that every one of our holidays and so much of our history is tied to, be it Tu Bishvat marking the blossoming of the trees **in Israel**, Sukkot celebrating the harvest **in Israel**, or Hanukkah celebrating the rededication of the Temple after the revolt against the Seleucids **in Israel**, then the correct solution, in both Europe **and** the Middle East, was to not treat Jews like second-class citizens on a good day and vermin on a bad one.
Under the rule of the caliphs, Jews and Christians were categorized as dhimmi, or “protected” peoples. Under such terms, they paid a special tax, the jizya, and received the state’s “protection” in return.
That “protection” entailed the following: they could not bear arms, ride horses, build new places of worship or repair existing ones, and they were required to dress in ways that set them apart.
Some rulers made these restrictions into rituals of public humiliation. In Egypt, the Fatimid caliph al-Hakim, who ruled from 996 to 1021, forced Jews to wear black robes, to put on bells when entering bathhouses, and to hang a wooden calf around their necks whenever they appeared in public.
Fez saw six thousand of its Jews slaughtered in 1033, and its Jewish community was attacked and massacred twice more, in 1276 and again in 1465.
In Spain, Granada suffered a similar fate in 1066, when roughly three thousand Jews lost their lives. Moroccan Jews faced further killings in 1790, and in 1912 the Jewish quarter of Fez was basically wiped out.
What happened to the Jews of Damascus in 1840 under the watch of Muhammad Ali’s Egypt? Why were 63 Jewish children kidnapped and imprisoned? It was because the Egyptian authorities, encouraged by the French consul, thought the Jews had disappeared a friar and stolen his blood to make matzah for Passover. A blood libel to a T.
How about Yemen? Jews were pressured to convert, and orphans were seized from their families and forced to give up their religion. The community had to smuggle those who had lost their parents to British-controlled Aden to prevent this from happening.
The same thing happened in Mashhad, Iran, in 1839 – forcible conversions of 700 families under the threat of death.
Maimonides wrote the following to the Jews of Yemen **in 1172** in what is known as the Epistle to Yemen. They had initially written to him for advice, as they were being pressured to convert by the local authorities:
“God has hurled us in the midst of this people, who have persecuted us severely, and passed baneful and discriminatory legislation against us, as Scripture has forewarned us.… Never did a nation molest, degrade, debase and hate us as much as they.”
Jews were murdered, confined, kidnapped, and forcibly converted across the entire Middle East, culminating in hundreds of thousands of them being ethnically cleansed from their home countries in the region after Israel was founded.
There are barely any Jews left in any of the lands of the caliphs because they were expelled. Any attempt to whitewash this history under the notion that everything was kumbaya before Israel was founded is a total bastardization in the pursuit of a geopolitical objective: the destruction of the world’s only Jewish state.
The only way all of this can be reconciled is by trying to attack Israel’s legitimacy by saying none of this ever happened and that the connective tissue between Jews and this particular place is ahistorical. It’s a total farce, but that’s the only the only card left to play, because not doing this means the entire house of cards comes tumbling down.