Likes https://x.com/ElliotMalin/status/2120907379541975485.
A tweet by ElliotMalin
x.com
“Whether a hospital in #Gaza was used for acts harmful to the enemy is not a question either party to the armed conflict has credibility to answer.” Ummm that’s not how that works. If a hospital is used for acts harmful to the enemy, warning has been given, and proportionality assessments don’t demonstrate higher incidental harm than the strategic military gain, then the party has a credible claim to defend the attack. Something I find fascinating is how many in this space make rash conclusions without substantiating their position or a full assessment of the legality of such strikes. Also, an independent fact finder is not going to be consulted to a military strike prior to its commencement. In no world is that a thing that happens. Making a special case for Gaza is nonsensical. Changing the rules in Gaza has made the situation worse for Palestinians because it has exercised to excuse Hamas from agency for its own actions that has caused exponentially more harm to them. It’s immoral and legally dubious. Also, just a casual reminder that Janina is not a lawyer and holds no law degree but often portrays herself as a legal expert. In any other area of law in the world this would be sanctionable.
39 °F Overcast Clouds