Dear @VP @JDVance
The “forever war” line only works if you treat the conflict as something the United States started and can simply walk away from. That simply isn’t what is happening with Iran and its proxies. And it’s this total lack of understanding of who and what they are that makes your entire view and argument invalid, but it also makes it dangerous for the American people you allege to be somehow protecting.
Iran and the groups it arms and directs have treated Israel, American forces, and Western targets as legitimate for decades. That posture didn’t begin with any recent US decision and it does not require US troops on the ground to continue. The fatwas, the funding, the weapons shipments, and the attacks themselves are the war.
Have you ever once asked yourself what military action Argentina, for example, did to warrant multiple mass casualty bombings that murdered hundreds?
Choosing not to respond doesn’t miraculously end those actions. All it does is leave the initiative with the side that has already decided the fight is ongoing.
Israel’s situation is different in degree but not in kind. It faces groups whose stated objective is not a negotiated border adjustment but the destruction of the state. That objective has never been abandoned after previous rounds. Netanyahu didn’t start this, nor has anything Netanyahu or his government have done made it any better or worse. The Arabs have been murdering and massacring Jews on that land well before 1948, well before the Balfour Declaration, and even well before modern political Zionism of the late 1890’s.
Treating every Israeli response as the cause of the next round ignores the pattern that preceded it. And that ignoring of the pattern and history and the treatment of Israel by blaming Israel and Jews isn’t anything other than deliberate, and to be honest, evil. You’re not using intellect or morality or even patriotism. You’re using theological fallacy and ideology. That’s the opposite of patriotism and leadership. Your behavior and your actions are no different to Iran.
The practical choice for the United States is narrower than the isolationist framing allows. One option is to accept that attacks will continue and try to manage the costs. But you’ll quickly find out that this option is self-defeating. The other option is to raise the costs high enough that the other side’s ability or willingness to keep conducting them is reduced. Neither option ends the underlying ideology. Both are responses to a conflict that is already underway not decisions that create it, whether you like and accept it or not.
If you genuinely and wholeheartedly believe that America removing troops and equipment from the region and refusing to fight back is going to end the war the Islamic regime and Muslim world as a whole have chosen to wage on America and the West, then as is abundantly obvious, you should be nowhere near the White House, leadership, or even in the position to have and give an opinion. You’re not protecting the American people and you are absolutely not a patriot. You’re just a common dangerous theological ideologue who is endangering the people you are supposed to represent.